Skip to main content

Is Manny Machado a DIRTY player?

Over the past couple of seasons, including just last night Manny Machado has found himself involved in a few instances of where his late-slides into second base have at least in my opinion, have labled him as a "Dirty" player.

Example number one is very vivid to Red Sox fans, including myself.  While playing for the Orioles, Machado while sliding into second base, is seen CLEARLY, with his cleat facing up thus resulting in both injuring and then leaving a crumpled Pedroia laying near second base.
  This injury not only affected Pedroia ability to stay on the field last season, but its effects lingering into this season where he only was able to be on the field for three games.
Here is Machado's slide into Pedroia where you clearly again see Machado with his spike up impaling Pedroia.
Machado "dirty slide into Pedroia"
This led to the infamous Matt Barnes pitches over Machado's head a couple days later, and the video of Pedroia telling Machado' that "It wasn't him" that had potentially ordered as deemed in the "Code of Baseball" to retaliate.

 Now just a year later, You would think potentially that he would learn a lesson from what occured with Pedroia??? NOPE twice, yes TWICE he went into Brewers shortstop  Orlando Arcia causing on the first a no-throw and a run to score. But, it's on his second slide into second base where Machado is blatantly seen reaching out and grabbing onto Arcia's leg thus forcing the shortstop into throwing wildly to first base.
  The first play wasn't challenged by Brewers manager, Craig Counsell, but the second one WAS, and it resulted in a double play caused by the interference by Machado.
Manny Machado illegal slide

The reason that this could be considered an issue is that it was only a couple years ago when Chase Utley who has had his own history of late slides into whoever is covering the second base bag on potential double-plays be deemed as like his current teammate on the Dodgers, Machado as dirty himself.
In this clip you will see multiple sides by Utely including the one where he slides late and into Mets shortstop Rubin Tejada, resulting with Tejada breaking his leg.
Chase Utley history of dirty slides
As you can hear in the broadcast, that this slide is known as a barrel-roll used to be very common in past seasons and used to "break-up" the double play from being completed.
 However, in this instance, Utely deliberately goes out of his path in the baseline- to "go after" Tejada and it again results in both Utley getting a concussion as well as Tejada breaking his leg.
 Following the post-season of 2016, MLB reviewed this slide among others and created what is known now as the "Utely rule" but for those who are wanting to know what is in this rule go here.
MLB Slide Rule ( Utely Rule explained)
 What I am getting at here, is while yes this slide was popular among baserunners thirty plus years ago, in today's age and style of play where protecting players from injuries is viewed by many including those in the commissioners office as relevant to today's style of baseball then players such as the soon to be retired Utley and his current Dodger teammate, Machado need to be taught a lesson either by being suspended by MLB for more than 30 games or how about a year suspension.
Either way, Utely, and Machado while some may consider them hard-nosed players, and their slides as just trying to break up potential double-plays,  in today's version of Baseball, those slides are now viewed as illegal and need to stop.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

looking back on a year gone past

So lets see whats been up with me .. well as another holiday season draws closer to an end, I am looking back on the year that was. It started out with me loosing a job coincidentally on new years eve day of 2009 and then a month later I began working as free lance videographer which I still do to this very day. In April I resumed my umpiring for a 7th year in a row and also had a wonderful and exciting trip to visit my sister in new york city. I continued umpiring till mid july when I was part of my first theatrical production in over a year. I loved being part of the cast of 42nd St and also while doing that became part of another cast, this one for Barber of Seville. Both shows brought a new widening of my horizons and brought new friends and oppertunities into my life In October I had my 26th birthday and it was another wonderful time.. In November I took myself to see my first concert in over 5 years when Rockapella came to town. I also celebrated the one year anniversary of ...

Why Kevin Youkillis is the perfect blueprint for how Red Sox should handle Rafael Devers

photo credit: Cincinnati Enquier^.com Kevin Youkilis over 8.5 years with the Red Sox provided grit, determination, ^ a power-bat. Yet it was his defensive versatility that let the Red Sox get better. When the Red Sox drafted Kevin Youkilis out of the University of Cincinnati where he put together a .410/.549/.714/1.263 offensive stat line. Yet it was the fact that Youkilis also led the nation with 59 walks compared to just striking out just 21 times, that attracted then-GM Theo Epstein to draft the young third baseman in the 8th round of the 2001 draft. Youkilis would spend three seasons in the minors before reaching the M ajors during the 2004 season, where he would play a minor role that season during the team's championship run, appearing in 72 games that year , hitting .260 with 7 home-^runs driving in 35. Yet between 2007 and 2011 is when Youkilis would truly prove to be one of the best players in the game.  Over that five years, Youkilis would average 1...
Soo as we start the beginning of week #3 I have come to the realization that as much as I want to be like all the other guys who are here umpiring, I need to be able to listen to my body and adjust certain things to make it possible to actually umpire correctly.  My knee is still in one place the swelling has continued to go down but the soreness is still there. Hopefully by Tuesday or Wednesday I can slowly start ramping it up again and won't have lost too much time.